Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Wyrd Smythe's avatar

Great! I got a bit more than halfway through T&G, got distracted, and never got back to it. A series of discussion posts from you about it should encourage me to get back to it. (And to your thesis, which I also put down and never got back to. I'm apparently very easily distracted these days.) I'd be especially interested in drilling down on what Neal means by 'truth'. For instance, if you say to me, "I put the pig in the pen in the backyard," I would easily disambiguate your meaning but understand you to be representing a fiction. (Or, under the circumstances, a gag.) Which left me a little hung on the horns of a 'truthful fiction.' But there is an older meaning of 'true' -- 'straight' or 'accurate', as in a 'true saw cut'.

The meaning of truth was a more immediate problem for me in your poll above. I was forced into "Not sure / none of the above" (which seem two different categories) because I think truth is foremost subjective. So, I'm sure my answer is "None of the above!" :)

Expand full comment
Ed Gibney's avatar

Ha ha what a clever book trailer! I like the way you took over the narration to, I'm guessing, paper over some production issues? : ) I look forward to digging into the issues with you and Neal over the posts ahead!

Expand full comment
9 more comments...

No posts